Editorial: Commercially Manufactured Bioidentical Hormones
It is very disappointing that Wyeth Laboratories has filed a complaint with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). The complaint contains some inaccurate information and appears to be written by someone that is not totally aware of the history and intricacies of bioidentical hormone therapy (BHRT), commercial products that have been and are currently available, and pharmaceutical compounding that is initiated by physicians and patients. It appears to be aimed at discrediting physicians and pharmacists that are dedicated to working together to individualize patient care through pharmaceutical compounding. In this short space, there is not room to address all the issues, but I have addressed just a few.
- The active ingredients that naturally occur in the body, are FDA-approved ingredients and many are commercially available but not necessarily in the dosage forms, strengths, or specific combinations needed by patients.
- These hormones have been studied extensively in clinical trials.
- These hormones are natural to the human body and are identical to what the body has been, and still is, producing (but not in sufficient quantities as one ages).
- The hormones all have individual official USP monographs in the current U.S. Pharmacopeia (Estradiol USP; Estriol USP; Estrone USP; Progesterone USP; Testosterone USP).
The vast majority of compounding for BHRT involves estradiol, estriol, estrone, progesterone, and testosterone. All these have been in commercially available, manufactured products over the years, still are available, and, as such, undergo clinical trials prior to approval. (Estrone may not be commercially available now but has been in the past.)
USP monographs for estradiol, in addition to the bulk substance, include Estradiol Vaginal Cream USP, Estradiol Pellets USP, Estradiol Injectable Suspension USP, and Estradiol Tablets USP. USP monographs for estrone, in addition to the bulk substance, include Estrone Injection USP and Estrone Injectable Suspension USP. USP monographs for progesterone, in addition to the bulk substance, include Progesterone Injection USP, Progesterone Intrauterine Contraceptive System USP, Progesterone Injectable Suspension USP, and Progesterone Vaginal Suppositories USP. USP monographs for testosterone, in addition to the bulk substance, include Testosterone Injectable Suspension USP. These lists do not include any of the ester forms of the hormones.
Let's look at some of the COMMERCIAL products that contain the same ingredients as compounded preparations that the Wyeth letter says are dangerous, unapproved, and should not be compounded.
ESTRADIOL |
| Activella Tablets | Novo Nordisk |
| Alora Transdermal System | Watson |
| Climara Transdermal System | Berlex |
| CombiPatch Transdermal System | Novartis |
| Esclim Transdermal System | Women First |
| Estrace Vaginal Cream | Warner Chilcott |
| Estrace Tablets | Warner Chilcott |
| Estradiol Tablets | Watson |
| Estradiol Tablets | Mylan |
| Estradiol Transdermal System Patches | Mylan |
| Estrasorb | Novavax |
| Estring Vaginal Ring | Pharmacia & Upjohn |
| Gynodiol | Fielding |
| Hormonin No. 1 & No. 2 | Carnrick (No longer available). |
| Menostar | Berlex |
| Prefest Tablets | Monarch |
| Vagifem Tablets | Novo Nordisk |
| Vivelle Transdermal System | Novartis |
| Vivelle-Dot Transdermal System | Novartis |
|
ESTRIOL |
| Hormonin No. 1 & No. 2 | Carnrick (No longer available). |
|
ESTRONE |
| Bestrone | Bluco |
| Estrogenic Substances Aqueous (mainly estrone) | Various |
| Estrone Injectable Suspension |
| | Foygen Aqueous | Foy Laboratories |
| Hormonin No. 1 & No. 2 | Carnrick (No longer available) |
| Kestrone 5 | Hyrex |
| Par-Supp | Parmed |
| Propagon-S | Spanner |
| Theelin | No longer available |
|
PROGESTERONE |
| Crinone Gels | Serono |
| Estrogestin A | Harvey |
| Prochieve Gel | Columbia |
| Prometrium Capsules | Solvay |
| Progesterone Injection | Watson and others |
|
TESTOSTERONE |
| Androderm Transdermal System | Watson |
| Androgel | Unimed |
| Striant Mucoadhesive | Columbia |
| Testim Gel | Auxilium |
| Testoderm Transdermal System | Alza |
| Testopel | Bartor Pharmacol |
Sad to say, it is apparent that Wyeth is again trying to protect its financial interests following the situation involving its conjugated estrogens product and the Women's Health Initiative trials. It is very hard to respect a company that is intent on doing harm to pharmacies that have served for years in distributing and supporting Wyeth's products. It is also hard to respect a company that does not want patients to receive the best treatment possible�one-size does not fit all patients. But, then again, it may be a sign of the times when so many entities misrepresent and falsify public disclosures and documents for their own gain. But that still does not make it right!
Loyd V. Allen, Jr., Ph.D., R.Ph
Editor-in-Chief |